Are These the Dolans I’ve Been Looking For?

Are These the Dolans I’ve Been Looking For?

PLEASE NOTE: Melody is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.

This post contains affiliate links. When you click on these links and make a purchase, I earn a percentage of the sale which allows me to keep providing you great content for free on this website.


If you’re a regular reader of my blog you know that I’m on what seems like a neverending quest to figure out who the Dolan’s in Patrick Dolan’s reinstated probate file were.  The quest has sent me in circles like a crazed character in a Looney Tunes cartoon.

A Little Background

Patrick Dolan died in 1905.  But, his probate was not settled before the 1906 earthquake and fire in San Francisco.  The probate proceedings were refiled by his niece, Mary (Kelly) Meincke.  When the probate was reinstated, the California and Massachusetts cousins fought over who was Patrick’s true heir.

The probate file is a gold mine of information.  While it is a great source of information, it leaves many unanswered question.  One of them is why William and Thomas Dolan mentioned in Patrick Dolan’s obituary were left out of the proceedings.

patrick dolan obituary san francisco 1905
Patrick Dolan’s obituary lists some of his nieces and nephews (Source: San Francisco Call)

Who Were William and Michael Dolan?

I have no clue.  If you know, please tell me!  All I know is their names are in Patrick Dolan’s obituary and they were alive in 1905.

I have no proof that there was another Dolan family in San Francisco.  For all I know William and Michael never left Ireland.

I’m making the assumption that because they were named in the obituary and the Boston cousins were not, that Patrick’s niece had contact with them.

And, I have to start somewhere, right?

Irish San Francisco is available on Amazon.com

This is a wonderful pictorial history of the Irish in San Francisco.  Maybe I’ll find William and Michael hiding in these photos.

Figuring Out Who They Were Without Their Parents’ Names

I guess I like a challenge because I’ve spent a couple of years trying to figure out who William and Michael belonged to.  This is the criteria I’ve used to sort it out:

  1.  Father was born in Co. Roscommon, Ireland.
  2.  Parents may have been in Massachusetts first, then came to San Francisco.
  3.  Father died before Patrick Dolan in 1905.
  4.  Dolan family must have two sons Michael and William presumably of the same age as their cousins by 1900.
  5.  Only Michael and William are alive by 1905 when Patrick Dolan’s obituary is published.

Sounds easy, doesn’t it?  HA!  Their are so many Dolans in San Francisco between 1860 and 1900 that I might as have been looking for every Irish family who came to the great city before the earthquake and fire.

This Family or That Family?

I narrowed down the possibilities to two families that fit my requirements.  In I Found John Dolan’s Obituary, I summarized how I eliminated one family when I found the patriarch’s obituary.  John Dolan was from the wrong county in Ireland.  It was the wrong family.

Michael Dolan was my next candidate and he looked more promising.  To start with, he was born in the right place: Athlone, Co. Roscommon, Ireland.

michael dolan obituary san francisco
Michael Dolan died in San Francisco in 1890 (Source:  San Francisco Call)

Michael married a woman named Honorah or Hannorah (aka Hannah). Michael and Honorah were in Cambridge, MA in the 1850s where they had two children:  Michael and Elizabeth.  Then, they headed out to San Francisco where they had three more:  Thomas, William, and George.

I’ve followed the family through the census and death records.  This is what I know so far:

Michael Dolan, b. ca 1830, Athlone, Co. Roscommon, Ireland; d. 1890, San Francisco, CA.

m.  Honorah ???

  1. Michael
  2. Elizabeth aka Lizzie and Eliza m. ??? Flanagan
  3. Thomas m. Maggie ???
    1. May
    2. Alice
    3. Gertrude m. Francis Joseph Hanley
      1. Francis Joseph Hanley Jr.
  4. William
  5. George

So far so good!  We’ve got a Michael and we’ve got a William.

The problem is I can’t establish when the children died. The only thing I can confirm is Thomas is alive in 1900 and recorded in the 1900 US Federal Census.  His mother was living with him as well.

It appears he may still be alive in 1910 if an entry in the city directory is him.

Is this another dead end?

I Am Not Ready to Toss Them Out

Since I know that Mary (Kelly) Meincke did not name Patrick Dolan’s nieces and nephews who lived in Boston in his obituary, is it possible that she wasn’t all that clear on who her Dolan cousins were?  In her grief, did she mix up names?  If she made an error, then I might be on the right track.

Then again, if Mary Meincke was confused, I could be looking for a Michael and William Dolan who never existed!

I do know this.  In Thomas Coyne’s Will Settles It, I show that the Boston cousins knew all about their uncle’s death.

Snippet from Thomas Coyne's Will
A portion of the will of Thomas Coyne tells me everything I need to know about his knowledge of Patrick Dolan

And, in conversations with a descendant of that line, I know that one of Patrick’s nephews made a trip out to San Francisco before Patrick died.  The family has his diary to prove it.

Why are the Irish So Difficult to Research?

I’ll hold onto this family’s information.  Maybe I’ll find the missing piece to prove or disprove the connection.

  • Michael Dolan Sr. voted which means he became a citizen.  It is possible there is a naturalization record that will have the answer I seek?
  • Is it possibly I might locate mortuary records showing that Patrick Dolan paid for plots for this Dolan family as well as my Kelly’s?
  • Will a DNA match hold the key to who William and Michael Dolan really are?

What I really need is a genealogy fairy godmother who waves her magic wand and says “I know which family you are looking for!”


I’m not holding out hope on that fairy godmother thingy.

Do you have an impossible genealogy problem that you’re working on? Have you solved one? Tell us about it in the comments.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *